Lee County Women's Tennis League

Appeals For 2009 updated May 18, 2009

An appeal is defined as a player requesting to play down one level below her rating.  Example:  A player with a 4.0 rating requests to play on a team in the 4.0 minus division. Because a lower rated player may play up two levels on a higher rated team, appeals are not accepted to raise a player’s rating.

The appeals committee did not grant any requests for a player to play up beyond what the roster rules allow.

Any rating appeal granted to play down one division is valid for one year only.   

The actual rating does not change; however, the appeal allows the player to play down one rated division and in some cases, the corresponding 50+ division.

The restrictions associated with the appeal to play down are
1 appealed player per match on court 1 only
 keeping in mind that each captain must  play strength according to her judgment. 

An appeal denied to a player requesting to play down one division was based on a review of the player’s rating, her match history, her win-loss record and the number of times her match scores beat the spread.

For medical reasons such as major surgery; i.e., hip or knee replacement, a player may request to re-rate down.  The player must send an email to the LCWTL Director by October 1 with a brief explanation for this request.  (Please DO NOT include doctor’s notes or medical records.)

Appeals Granted for players appealing to play down one division:

must play on court 1

Name                                                  Club                      Rating      Division Requested

Luzc  Bingcang               

Pelican Preserve 3.5 3.5-
Carling Carpenter Colonial  4.5-  4.0
Janet Craycraft   Various 4.5- 4.0
Rose Giro Pelican Preserve 3.5  Silver
Penny Koch Pelican Preserve 3.5  Silver
Judy Nicolosi                                     Lexington 4.0 4.0-/Gold
Anneka Randt  MidCape   4.0 4.0-/Gold
Nancy Solum Heritage Palms 4.0- 3.5
Gerrie Weaver Cross Creek  3.0 3.0-
Vera Lingeman Del Tura  3.5  3.5-/Silver
Karen Ackert  Gulf Harbour 3.5  Silver
Jennifer Boulton FMRC  4.0- 3.5
Bonnie Buckley Landings 4.5- 4.0 
Robin Cohan Dunes 4.0- 3.5
Marianne Crouch Gulf Harbour 4.0- 3.5
Ruth Ann Edelman Gulf Harbour 3.5 Silver
Wesley Fay Dunes 4.5- 4.0
Linda Green Herons Glen 3.5- 3.0
Donilyn Keesling  Herons Glen 4.0- 3.5
Sheri McNulty Pelican Landing  4.0- 3.5
Sherry Newland  Various 4.5- 4.0
Marjorie Pacheco Dunes 4.0- 3.5
Bev Patterson CCYC 4.5- 4.0
Darlene Pillars  Vines 3.5- 3.0
Putzi Reitter Lexington 4.0 4.0-/Gold
Joan Stevenson DelTura 4.5- 4.0

 

Appeals Denied for players appealing to play DOWN one division:

An appeal denied to a player requesting to play down one division was based on a review of the player’s rating, her match history, her win-loss record and the number of times her match scores beat the spread.

Name                                                      Club                       Rating               Division requested

 

BJ Brundage Fiddlesticks  4.0  Gold
Marianne Crouch Gulf Harbour 4.0- Silver
Rena Gezzar Del Tura 4.5-  4.0
Peggy Henry Heritage Palms 4.0 Gold
Jennifer Hetherington Heritage Palms 4.5- 4.0
Betsy Howlet Cross Creek 3.0 3.0-
Pat Klebba Vines/Park Meadow 4.0- Silver
Jemin Martinson  Gulf Harbour 4.5- 4.0
Sandra Murphy Cypress Lake 4.0- 3.5
Suzanne Santillo CCYC  4.5- 4.0
Donna Schmidt Landings 3.5 Silver
Diane Schwab Gulf Harbour 4.5- 4.0
Kathy Slattery Kelly Greens 4.0- 3.5
Carol Smoot Landings 3.5  Silver
Jane Suter Forest  4.0- 3.5-
Mary Varnum Cross Creek 4.0 Gold
Nancy Watson CCYC 4.0 Gold
Nancy Yavorsky Landings 3.5 Silver

 

Appeals Denied for players requesting to play UP:

Because a lower rated  player may play up two levels on a higher rated team, appeals are not accepted to raise a player’s rating.

 

Name

Club

Computer Rating at
end of season

Division Requested
Maureen Brooks Pelican Landing 4.0- 4.0
Stephanie Freeman Gulf Harbour 3.0- 3.0  
Mary Harrington Gulf Harbour 3.5 4.0
Sharon Hillard Pelican Sound 3.0- Silver
Henri LaLiberty FMRC 3.0-  3.5-
Carolyn Nickerson Park Meadow 3.0 3.5-/Silver
Anna Pitts Gulf Harbour 3.5- 3.5
Flo Williams Beachview 3.5- 4.0 

 

 

Copyright © 2005 Audrey Palmer . All rights reserved.
Revised: May 18, 2009